MOJO
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Contact
  • Comment
  • Testimonials
  • Donate
COPFS3
June 26 2018

Non Disclosure – Response

Euan News

Our “Comment” article of 19 June, “Non Disclosure – Another Angle”, was picked up this past weekend by the “Sunday Post”.  Their short piece is reproduced here:

 

Justice campaigners: Appeals blocked by evidence ban

Criminals trying to appeal their convictions are being denied access to evidence by the Crown Office, a charity has claimed.

The Glasgow-based Miscarriages of Justice Organisation (MOJO) claims prosecutors are not releasing files to them as part of their work in preparing appeal cases for people.

There is a legal requirement to hand over any material evidence used by the prosecution to anyone planning to appeal their conviction.

However, a MOJO spokesman said: “We are assisting a client whose murder conviction causes us concern. The client has no access to legal aid.

“Our request of the Crown Office that we be allowed access, with the client’s authority, to the prosecution evidence was met with a summary refusal.”

The Crown Office said disclosure to third parties can only be done when there is a legal basis and it is in the public interest to do so.

A spokeswoman added: “The Crown Office recognises the importance of the legal obligation to assess and disclose evidence.

“Where disclosure issues are raised in relation to any specific case, The Crown Office has processes in place to respond appropriately.”

 

Ignore, for a moment, the illuminating opening word.   If the function of the press is simply to give an uncritical platform to the wielders of state authority then clearly we can have no complaint about what was published by the Sunday Post.  But we do complain.   This is a serious subject.   It deserves serious treatment.  We won’t simply accept that the Crown Office – the prosecuting authority in Scotland – should be the sole arbiter of what of their evidence the person they have accused can and cannot see.   They say that they “recognise the importance of the legal obligation to disclose evidence.”   And then they refuse, point blank, to disclose evidence.   Why, then, are they free to ignore their obligation?   The answer can only be inferred, since the question wasn’t asked, and it appears to be that the Crown Office sees itself also as the arbiter of what is “in the public interest”.

Remember, please, that the institution taking to itself the role of referee is one of the combatants in this fight.   And read, in that context, their assurance that they “respond appropriately” to requests from prisoners who are asking only to exercise their legal rights.

SpyCops Meeting, Glasgow Eddie Gilfoyle

Related Posts

0E5O0177

Comment, News

Alistair Bonnington: Malkinson offers a timely warning as Scotland sleepwalks into normalising injustice

In a hard-hitting article published today by Scottish Legal News, Alistair Bonnington identifies many of the serious concerns that we – and many others with experience of the Scottish criminal justice system – have voiced over the Scottish Government’s proposed Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill, currently working its way through the Scottish Parliament. […]

Malkinson3

News

Miscarriage of justice watchdog in the cross-hairs

The Andy Malkinson case is showing remarkable resilience in terms of its ability to hold the interest of the media. This type of story would normally last one news cycle or, perhaps, two – a matter of hours. It is deeply gratifying to see the continued and widespread press examination of this case, a month […]

Coroner+Rules+Birmingham+Pub+Bombing+Inquest+TONcWyXD0fTx

News

Ethical, Moral and Legal Turpitude

The Independent reports, today, on a decision by the Crown Prosecution Service to bring no charges, following the “re-investigation” of the Birmingham pub bombings. Julie Hambleton, whose sister Maxine was killed in the atrocity, and who has fought tirelessly for justice over the intervening decades, describes that decision as “ethical, legal and moral turpitude”. It […]

Latest Tweets

→ Follow us

Archives

Search

  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Contact
  • Comment
  • Testimonials
  • Privacy Notice
© Miscarriages of Justice Organisation (Scotland) 2023 - Company No SC239555 - Registered Charity No SC033820 The work of MOJO is financially supported by the Scottish Government