From the BBC’s On this Day feature we repost the following piece.
Angela Cannings was wrongfully convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment following the tragic death of her children to Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).
At trial, Professor Sir Roy Meadow gave evidence based on his calculations of the probability or likelihood of a second cot death within the same family. This evidence partially lead to Angela’s wrongful conviction.
It was later established that genetic inheritance was the likely explanation for the increased instances of tragic infant death within the family.
The paediatrician was initially struck-off by the General Medical Council due to evidence given at Ms Cannings’ trial.
Meadow was later reinstated on appeal, after a ruling that his error did not amount to serious professional misconduct.
On this day, 10 December 2003, Ms Cannings’ conviction was quashed after a five-day appeal.
The quashing of Angela’s conviction, as well as other high-profile cases such as Sally Clark, resulted in a review into 297 other cases involving expert testimony.
The original piece can be found HERE.
2003: Mother cleared of murdering babies
The Court of Appeal has overturned the conviction of a mother jailed for life for the murder of her two baby sons.
Angela Cannings, 40, from Salisbury in Wiltshire, was sentenced in April 2002 for the murder of seven-week-old Jason in 1991, and 18-week-old Matthew in 1999.
Ms Cannings has always maintained the two boys died of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), also known as cot death. SIDS was recorded as the cause of the death of her first daughter, Gemma, who died at the age of 13 weeks in 1989.
Ms Cannings has one surviving daughter, born in 1996.
The three judges took just four minutes to quash Ms Cannings’ conviction after a five-day appeal.
During the hearing, the judges heard that Ms Cannings’ relatives had also lost babies.
They were also given recent research suggesting the recurrence rate of SIDS after a prior cot death is almost six times greater than in a “normal” family.
The evidence discredited the controversial opinion of expert witness Professor Sir Roy Meadow that, unless proved otherwise, one cot death is a tragedy, two are suspicious and three are murder.
In delivering the verdict, Lord Justice Judge said not enough was known scientifically about the causes of cot deaths for juries to exclude natural causes of death in such cases.
“The door never seems to be closed to new views about what may or may not cause cot death,” he said.
After the conviction was overturned, Ms Cannings said, “These last four years have been a living hell.
“Finally today justice has been done and my innocence has been proved. I would like to go home now and be mummy to our very precious daughter.”
This is the third case this year in which a mother accused of killing her babies has walked free.
In January, solicitor Sally Clark, given a life sentence for murdering her two baby sons, was freed on appeal after spending more than three years in prison.
And in June, 35-year-old pharmacist Trupti Patel was cleared of murdering her three babies by a jury at Reading Crown Court.
Sir Roy Meadow was also involved as a prosecution witness in these cases.
The government has ordered a review of the procedures used for investigating mothers accused of murdering their own babies.
The judges involved in the Angela Cannings appeal later called for a halt to the prosecution of parents for murdering their babies when expert evidence points to the possibility of cot death.
They also said that cases against parents accused of killing their children were unsafe if they relied purely on expert evidence.
The Attorney General announced a general inquiry into 258 cases – most of which relied heavily on the evidence of expert witnesses, including Sir Roy Meadow – where parents were accused of killing their children. The number was later raised to 298.
The Attorney General finally identified 28 cases where parents convicted of killing their children had grounds for appeal. Five are already being looked at by the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
They include the case of Donna Anthony, given two life sentences in 1998 for the murder of her two babies.
The General Medical Council is to investigate Professor Meadow’s fitness to practise. The case is expected to be heard in early 2005.